Welcome to Thirsty Mermaid
At Thirsty Mermaid, located in the heart of Key West, we embrace the art of seafood salads with a casual yet classy vibe. Our story revolves around creating an intimate dining experience, featuring fresh, locally-sourced ingredients. From the delightful Mermaid Caesar salad with seared diver scallops to our raw bar offerings like the Mermaid Royale Platter, every dish is crafted with care. Families and groups can savor our diverse menu while enjoying our engaging atmosphere. With attentive service and a commitment to sustainable practices, Thirsty Mermaid invites you to indulge in a memorable culinary experience where the flavors of the ocean come alive.
Thirsty Mermaid: Reviews & Ratings
We came here for a late lunch and loved that it was off the beaten path a little bit. There was a lite crowd inside the small space and we got a table in the middle of the restaurant. Our server was with us immediately and we were presented with the lunch menu and main menu. There were a lot of sandwiches on the menu and luckily my wife saw the specials on the chalkboard behind me because we were never told about them. We got the tuna carpaccio appetizer off that menu and it was not a lot of food, but so good. The citrus made the dish. For my entree, I got the local snapper sandwich. I also had some of the soft shell crab sandwich, which was messy to eat and fell apart instantly. Both of the sandwiches were good, but not great, and had too much mayo. I also had a bite of the grilled cheese and that was amazing! Lots of cheese and so gooey!
Stopped in for happy hour and was pleasantly surprised with the options. Their happy hour is a nice way to try a variety of things at a discounted rate. Food was fresh and service was attentive. I recommend getting there as soon as they open. Dining room is intimate and fills up quickly.
Every time we come to key west we are going back to this place! Great happy hour, good food , amazing atmosphere and caring staff! See you soon!
Stumbled upon this place on our first night in Key West. Surprisingly we were seated immediately and the server was telling us about the specials. I got the grilled swordfish (special) and my boyfriend got the yellowfin tuna. We also ordered the clam chowder and it was one of the best chowders I've had. We ordered 1/2 dozen oysters (they had oysters from 3 different locations, we got 2 each). Super fresh, not too briny or fishy. Really fresh and delicious. Attentive staff, great ambiance, and amazing food. I'll definitely come back when I visit Key West!
Great service! Great food! Nice choice of Oysters! Ambiance was really nice. Will definitely return! Not a large place, so plan accordingly or call ahead.
My husband and I were recommended this place by a local tour guide and it was absolutely incredible. We had Natia as our server and she was incredible, friendly and helpful on choices. We had stone crab , shrimp cocktail and shrimp and scallop Caesar salad and it was all incredible !!
I know it's a tourist area, but the price is very very steep. The happy hour menu is good, but the portion is super tiny. You get a tiny ball of croquet for $8. All of the dishes were very good though. If you don't mind the price tag, definitely check this place out. The service is quick. The place is cute inside and the location can't be more prime.
Great spot for happy hour. We love the coastal decor and yummy small bites. A great spot to kick off your night. Last time we were there our server was great and so was the food. Felt like we got one of everything and I definitely recommend doing the same! Their oysters are delicious and my boyfriend likes their mermaid lager. The wings have a great sauce and you can't go wrong with the Mac and cheese bites. We really could have sat and enjoyed the a/c all night- but had to see the sunset. A must stop when visiting key west!
Location
-
521 Fleming St, Key West, FL 33040 Hotline: (305) 204-4828
Welcome to Thirsty Mermaid, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Key West at 521 Fleming Street. This trendy seafood salad eatery offers more than just a meal; it provides a delightful dining experience tailored for all ocean lovers and food enthusiasts. With an ambiance that strikes the perfect balance between casual and classy, it’s no wonder this culinary spot has quickly become a go-to destination for locals and visitors alike.
The first thing that strikes you upon entering Thirsty Mermaid is its intimate setting, ideal for groups but cozy enough for romantic dinners. The restaurant is wheelchair accessible and provides gender-neutral restrooms, showcasing a commitment to inclusivity. Plus, it’s dog-friendly! Arriving is a breeze with ample street parking and bike parking available.
Thirsty Mermaid specializes in seafood salads that highlight the charm of Key West’s coastal cuisine. Each dish showcases fresh, local ingredients, making for meals that are as vibrant as the surroundings. Start your culinary journey with tantalizing options from the raw bar, like the Ceviche Du Jour or the extravagant Mermaid Royale Platter, which features an impressive array of fresh oysters and shrimp cocktail. You can truly taste the ocean in each bite!
Don’t miss the salads, each with a unique twist. The Mermaid Caesar incorporates tender Key West pinks and seared diver scallops, while the Yellowfin Tuna Salad dances with a sesame ginger vinaigrette that perfectly balances flavor profiles. Whether you’re in the mood for a crunchy Island Wedge or a refreshing Mixed Baby Greens, the menu is designed to cater to different palates and dietary preferences.
For those craving a heartier meal, the burgers here do not disappoint. The Italian Burger with crispy prosciutto and caramelized onions is a tantalizing choice, while the classic yet delicious Good Ol Boy burger is a nod to comfort food that can’t go wrong.
Many happy hour aficionados recommend visiting Thirsty Mermaid for a delightful experience. Customers rave about the attentive service and the opportunity to enjoy a variety of dishes at discounted rates, making it an opportune spot for trying new flavors without breaking the bank. From fresh oysters to comforting clam chowder, the menu is packed with coastal classics that are bound to impress.
With a menu that constantly evolves and highlights the best of seasonal seafood, Thirsty Mermaid offers something for everyone. Don’t forget to ask about the daily specials for a truly unique treat! Whether you’re dining with kids or enjoying a night out with friends, the atmosphere is warm, inviting, and set with a moderate noise level, ensuring pleasant conversations flow easily.
In summary, if you find yourself strolling through Key West and have a penchant for seafood, make sure to stop by Thirsty Mermaid. With its delicious offerings, welcoming ambiance, and fantastic service, it’s more than just a meal; it’s a celebration of the flavors and spirit of the seaside. Dive in and indulge your taste buds—I guarantee you won’t regret it!
Contact: (305) 204-4828
